Tag Archives: Book Review

Half World by Hiromi Goto

Half World is one of those books that I pick up from time to time from the Children’s section where I work.  I find a poor, neglected volume that is due for return to the publisher, but which I can’t send back before at least trying first. I was somewhat surprised to find Half World on my returns list – not only is it an award-winner with an amazing cover, I was sure it had enough buzz to propel it along.  But life is tough at my bookstore – often without a staff member to love and recommend it, a book will die an undeserved death.  This is why I constantly lament the imbalance in my time/book ratio in life.  This time my efforts were rewarded – I found Half World to be a solid, satisfying fantasy with enough unusual elements to make it very enjoyable.

I loved the setup for Half World: there are three realms of existence: the Spirit Realm, the realm of Flesh, and Half World.  These realms are meant to be interconnected – we pass through Flesh to Spirit, or to Half Life if we must cleanse ourselves of something.  After a stretch in Half World we find release as a spirit; when our energy begins to flag we are reborn as flesh.  But somehow these realms have become disjointed: the spirit realm is drifting away as spirits forget their connection to flesh and slowly fade from existence; the flesh world is filled with dismay and discord without the release provided by the other two worlds; and those in half life are trapped, repeating their trauma and reliving their nightmares for an eternity.

In comes Melanie Tamaki, an unhappy fourteen-year-old who has been neglected by her mother and outcast by her peers.  Melanie doesn’t know that she belongs to two realms: her mother became pregnant in Half World and journied to the Wold of Flesh to raise her daughter.  Now, fourteen years later they are both being called back to repay a debt and to account for the impossibility of this life that was created in Half World.

Once it gets going, Half World becomes one of those child/teen-goes-to-a-strange-world-and-saves-it-then-returns-home-with-a-solution-to-his/her-original-problems book.  It’s such an overused plot that I have become quite impatient  with it.  Unless the book is special – we’re talking Narnia special – then I get very bored and annoyed.  I think I find these books tedious because they always end the same way – the world is saved and the character returns home with more than they originally sought.  If the ending is going to be that predictable, then I darn well want the main story to be unique and fascinating.

In this case, it was almost fascinating enough.  There is not much that is truly unique about Half World, but it does contain some great elements capably combined.  The feel is very Neil Gaiman, with a disturbing alternate world and some kind and clever guides (I’m thinking Neverwhere and Coraline in particular).  It has just the same level of threat and violence that you would find in one of his books.  The great villan (I won’t ruin his secret, which is one of the best parts of the book) is Mr. Glueskin.  In his gloopy, sticky and disguisting appearance, he reminded me of Diana Wynne Jones’ Howl’s Moving Castle, and slimy, depressed Howl.  These are wonderful authors to borrow from, and Hiromi Goto does a good job of creating a similar feel, but with a concept that stands all on its own.

The main character was interesting – Melanie has a good heart, but trouble remembering things, and she has never fit in.  I am actually quite pleased to see that there is a sequel coming out next spring because I’d like to see her grow up – there was just a hint of what she could become in this novel.  I would also enjoy seeing her in love, and being loved by someone romantically.  I think she could be remarkable if she was ever in her own element (I’m not sure what that would be though – she navigates our world and half world well, but doesn’t belong to either).

So I have been won over, and the book will stay on our shelves.  I enjoyed the Japanese elements and fantasy that borrowed from Asian sources.  There were amazing illustrations, and an interesting enough tale and characters to keep me moving through the well-drawn (though familiar) plot.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Fantasy, Just Read, Young Adult books

Odd Ball by Arthur John Stewart

Odd Ball is a new book set in my hometown, Victoria BC.  It’s actually set in a real school – Central Middle School – though Stewart does change the school’s age range from grades 6-8 to 7-9, and presumably lots of other details as well.

So I was bound to read it at some point, despite the tragically Canadian cover.  I picked it up now because it has just been nominated for the Victoria Book Prize (in the children’s category).  Seeing as I had already read and enjoyed last year’s Death Benefits, and I was still looking for a good YA book to put in my teacher newsletter, I picked up Odd Ball over the weekend.

I was very pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it.  It’s a slim volume and a quick read, but quite quirky, and I caught myself chuckling out loud more than once.  It reminds me most of Gordon Korman’s Schooled (a fantastic novel, as so many of his are) or Origami Yoda.  But it isn’t a rip-off: it’s got a character all of its own.  Like the two books above, it is told by many characters, particularly three middle school students: Kevin (the “coolest” geek of the school who refuses to accept this label because he can talk to girls unlike real geeks); Stephanie (a girl concerned about the deteriorating atmosphere of her school); and Paula (who is getting deeper and deeper into trouble at home and at school).  Other chapters are descriptions of past or present events by an omniscient narrator, and contributions by Victor, a first-year university student and former Latvian.

The plot really centres around Jobbi, a recent immigrant from Latvia who is target number one for bullies at Central Middle School.  While most students ignore or mock Jobbi and his thick accent, Stephanie and Kevin find something special in this kind and mysteriously insightful boy.  Unconsciously and effortlessly, Jobbi demonstrates that he might just have the abilities to solve the school’s social problems and bring the student body together.  It takes Stephanie, Kevin, a school dance, a trip to Latvia, some fancy skating, a sarcastic fortune-telling ball, and Jobbi’s unique sixth sense for matchmaking, but they make it happen.

As with Schooled and Origami Yoda it was fun learning about a very quirky character through the eyes of other people.  The Baltic connection reminded me of Holes, particularly the way problems and solutions were passed down through the generations.  Stewart also includes some good hockey scenes – you can tell he loves the game (though I can’t think of any middle school that actually has a team).  And the themes of bullying and gangs were handled quite well – the stakes were real and worrisome.  Occasionally there was a hint of a lesson-of-the-week kind of voice, particularly from the do-gooder Stephanie, but it didn’t harm the story in any serious way.  Overall, I thought it was unexpectedly delightful and I’m looking forward to recommending it, particularly to teachers.

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Just Read, Middle Grade Fiction

Witchlanders by Lena Coakley

I didn’t have high expectations for this book, though the beautiful cover immediately grabbed me.  But it has blown me away – this is my favourite YA fantasy in quite a while.  It is insightful, smart, innovative, and well written.  I can’t tell you how pleased I am to have found it.  From the ending it seems there will be sequels, and I am looking forward to following more of this story.

Witchlanders very much has a classic fantasy feel to it.  There is magic, peasant technology, and age-old enemies.  Ryder is a young man trying to hold his family together following his father’s death.  His mother’s increasingly erratic behaviour and dependence on Maiden’s woe – a flower that gives the power of prophesy, but is addictive and poisonous – is destroying the family balance.  When she foresees terrible events, Ryder refuses to believe in her or the magic of the witches who claim to protect his people.

The second point of view is the voice of Falpian, a young man sent into exile along the border by his disappointed father.  Falpian is one of the Baen, the old enemy of Ryder’s people.  The Baen’s magic is in song, though Falpian seems to have no skill in this art.  As Ryder and Falpian draw closer, an intangible connection between the would-be enemies grows stronger, and becomes a powerful bond that neither expected to find.

I won’t give away any more of the plot – but the themes of this book are incredible.  The brutality of war; the nature of difference, prejudice and ignorance; the necessity of challenging those in power who would lead without question; the subjugation of women; the importance of faith; and the connection of living things are all strong themes running through this book.

Witchlanders does what fantasy and sci-fi should do best – take us somewhere unfamiliar to remind us of our own world and its problems.  Unlike many YA fantasies that I have read, it doesn’t just skim the surface of magic/action/adventure – it digs deep and poses questions for the reader.  Here are two quotes that stopped me in my tracks:

“‘No,’ he said. ‘He is not on our side.  But Skyla, are we only allowed to care about people who are on our side?'”

“Do you think anyone is born a killer?  Do you think I was?  Trust me, I know what I’m asking.  An assassin’s first murder is himself.  He kills the man he was.”

[My apologies to Simon and Schuster – I’m not actually checking these quotes against the finished manuscript as I’m supposed to.  I’ll just have to hope they’re in the finished copy!]

Added to the complexity of ideas is the complexity of the characters.  Not only are the two main characters well-drawn, they have very conflicted but believable loyalties and impulses.  And the range of other character is satisfying. Most are a mix of bad and good: some intent on following orders; others follow an inner sense of what is right or a loyalty to a particular loved one; others are wrong-headed and misguided, but again are doing what their experience and world view tells them is right.  I don’t think anyone is truly evil, though many evil actions are performed.  Nor does everyone gets what they deserve – innocent or kind people are harmed and some awful people are never punished.  Some readers may find this frustrating; some might see it as simply an open door for a sequel (which I’m sure it is); I again found it a nice reflection on the unfairness of life and the unique ability of those in power to stay in power whatever their actions.

Though I clearly loved it, I recognize that Witchlanders is not for everyone.  It is high fantasy (though there are no dwarves or elves), and there is almost no hint of a love story.  Most won’t have the same reaction as me, and might experience only luke-warm enjoyment.  That said, I think the action and voices are strong enough to interest most people who are well-disposed to fantasy.  I sincerely hope that many people do give it a try, and that it is not lost or neglected in the mass of dystopian fiction making its way through the market right now.  Lena Coakley has created a gem, and it deserves a few moments to shine.

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Books I've loved, Fantasy, Just Read, Young Adult books

Forgotten by Cat Patrick

This is another one of those quasi-sci-fi books aimed at teen girls in the tradition Twilight, Hunger Games and Numbers.  While I kind of enjoyed Forgotten, it had some major issues that bothered me the whole way through.

I couldn’t quite get over the absolute impossibility of the premise in Forgotten – especially because the whys and hows were in no way explained.  London is a young woman whose memory works forward rather than backwards.  She can only remember the future, not her past.  As a result, she leaves herself notes every night so she can catch up on what is happening in her life.  While she can remember the next day, somewhere around 4am her memory resets, and she forgets it by morning.

Ok, interesting enough.  But – what the hell??  Memory doesn’t work like that – it’s just impossible.  And if you’re going to make me believe something impossible, I need a little bit more explanation for it all.  I mean, we’ve got some back story, but only vague references to how it started.  Really – she’s seeing the future – which I might be able to believe… but it’s a big stretch to call it memory and pretend it’s registered in her brain like normal memories are.  As if it’s something she’s already experienced.  Nifty idea, but please take some more effort to account for it.  And how is it that just her, her mom, and her best friend know about it?  Why haven’t they taken her to tons of specialists?  Why isn’t the government (or some other nefarious body) looking for her?  The best that could be said is that some of these things have happened, but she’s forgotten and hasn’t bothered reminding herself.

(A side note: in the book she apparently has beautiful auburn/red hair, but on the cover it’s just light brown? Why not check these things for continuity, publicity department?)

Another problem with the premise: she writes herself these notes every night, then every morning she has to catch herself up.  So presumably she’s reading hours of notes every day (sometimes she mentions this)… surely it’s increasing all the time and she has more and more and more to read.  How is it even possible to read through all the stuff she needs on a daily basis to function?  And why is it so important that her outfits are listed?  Can’t she go with what’s clean and what isn’t?  And how can she possibly ever pass a course, or a test?  By the time of the final review, she’d have no memory of the course at all.  But then, maybe she leaves a note as to what the questions will be… Oh, and one other thing: when reading these notes I was honestly very confused about whether she was talking about things that will happen to her that day (I think the wardrobe comments fall into this category) and what had happened the previous day.

What I did like was the thought experiment that is the concept – given adequate explanation, it could be really thought-provoking (and was a bit).  If you think about it, it’s a very sad life: as she gets older she has less and less to “remember”.  Her past disappears, and all she has left is a shrinking future.  By the time she’s old, she’ll be in a confusing present, without any memories to comfort her or guide her in the world.  That is endlessly thought-provoking, though the author doesn’t really delve into this at all.  In a way, I would have liked a more traditional sci-fi novel with this premise – it could have covered much more about her life and how it all happened, and how she manages to live it.  (or how a whole group of such people manage… makes you miss Philip K. Dick, even though I find a lot of his writing painful to read) As it was, I found it had a lot of the typical teen romance stuff re-hashed.  But, then, many readers are going to love that.

In terms of the re-hash: it’s got the usual parent stuff.  The usual friend stuff.  The usual school stuff. A very tall handsome boy named Luke who likes her.  Here the relationship reminded me of Twilight.  He’s the only person in London’s future that she can’t remember – so much so, that for a while she thinks he isn’t in her future (see Edward not being able to read Bella’s mind).  Their relationship is so immediately deep and close that it also reminds me of the vampire stuff.  Though of course it’s got a little of Fifty First Dates in it as well. I also think it is very similar to Numbers by Rachel Ward, about a girl with a strange and unsettling ability.  However, London is not a delinquent, and Luke is not nearly so hygiene challenged as Spider from that novel.  But it might be the closest match, genre-wise.

While well written and with some decent (though not very original) characters, Forgotten‘s main draw is it’s interesting premise.  If the gaps in explaining her memory issues don’t bother you, you’ll probably love this book.  If they do, I recommend finding some more serious sci-fi – like Philip K. Dick, Vonnegut, LeGuin, or maybe Asimov (if you like androids like I do).

Leave a comment

Filed under Just Read, Young Adult books

The Strange Case of Origami Yoda by Tom Angleberger

I probably wouldn’t have picked up this novel, except that I needed to review something for a teacher newsletter I’m doing.  A staff member said her kid loved this one – so what the heck, I thought.  Might as well try.

Again, I’m very glad it did.  This was another fun and funny read.  It’s not the best or most complex book – but it’s quirky and clever, and even a bit deep.  So not bad, not bad at all.  The idea is that Dwight is the school loser – most kids think he’s completely insane.  Maybe because he digs holes in his backyard and just sits in them; maybe because he wore the same shirt for a whole month; maybe because he says crazy things all the time.  In any case, one day Dwight (who is also amazing at origami) creates his own origami Yoda finger puppet.  Soon Yoda (who doesn’t sound much like Yoda) is giving students advice – and it is far more helpful, farsighted advice than Dwight could ever give.  So Tommy sets out to chronicle the Yoda incidents in order to sort out whether there might be supernatural powers inspiring Yoda’s advice – or whether Dwight is behind a very convincing hoax.

A very good read – and nice to watch the character of Dwight develop through his classmates’ eyes.  Great for fans of Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Star Wars, or even Gordon Korman’s Schooled (an even finer read that this one reminded me of).

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Just Read, Middle Grade Fiction

Earwig and the Witch by Diana Wynne Jones


This is a fantastic new primary book by one of my all-time favourite authors, Diana Wynne Jones.

If you haven’t already read her Chrestomanci series (particularly Charmed Life and The Pinhoe Egg), or Howl’s Moving Castle, then you should run out and get them. Now.  Right now.  Why are you still reading this?  Go get them!!  She was absolutely delightful, and has been in the biz for a long time (Charmed Life was written in 1973 – I was so sad to hear she had passed away March 2011).

Admittedly simpler than her books for older readers, Earwig and the Witch is about a young orphan named Earwig who is very good at getting her own way.  Though she has a “delightful” personality, she rather rules the roost at the orphanage and is not at all interested in being adopted.  Nevertheless, she is… by a witch (in poor disguise) named Bella Yaga and a nine-foot man named Mandrake who sometimes has horns.  Mandrake in particular is classic Diana Wynne Jones – he is a stern and smouldering presence through much of the story, until he (spoiler!) turns out to be an old softy.

A charming and fun book for young readers – I wish there were going to be more to look forward to.

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Fantasy, Just Read

Waiting for the Magic by Patricia MacLachlan

This is a new book by Patricia MacLachlan, author and Newbery Medal winner of Sarah, Plain and Tall.  I don’t often read books in the primary age range (from about 7-10), but I picked this one up anyway.  And I’m very glad that I did read it – it is a very sweet story with charming characters.

Though it is sweet, there is also a very serious narrative at the heart of this book.  It begins as William’s father abruptly leaves his family.  In response, William’s mom takes him and his little sister Elinor to the pet shelter, and they adopt four dogs and a cat.  Each dog has a distinct personality, and it soon becomes apparent that though William and his mom are remaining quiet about his father’s disappearance, the animals have lots to say. Indeed, the protective animals help the struggling family slowly pull itself back together. There is magic in hearing the animals, and it slowly spreads to everyone, alongside bravery, forgiveness, love and joy.

This is truly a captivating and comforting primary read, with lots of little laughs along the way.

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Just Read

The Vinyl Princess by Yvonne Prinz

I have been told to read this book a few times, but had never really gotten around to it until the other week when the straw finally broke the camel’s back.  I gave in after a friendly customer insisted it was great, and took it home from the store.  A week later I finally started reading it.  And I’m very glad I did – it is a very fun (and funny) read.

At sixteen Allie is the ultimate music aficionado: she has a huge vinyl record collection, an encyclopedic knowledge of music, and a long-standing job at Bob & Bob Records in Berkeley, California. As you may have sensed already, this is High Fidelity for teen girls, complete with the music snobbery (Allie regularly refuses to help customers locate their CD’s alphabetically – if they don’t know the alphabet, they have no business leaving home, let alone appearing in her store), strange but wonderful personalities, and exquisite humour (though not as exquisite as Nick Hornby’s – please please read his books if you haven’t already – High Fidelity, About a Boy and Long Way Down are all fantastic).

I particularly love Prinz’s characters: each one is detailed, real, and very odd. Allie is remarkably (and refreshingly) self-possessed and at home in her skin.  Though she does worry about her various flaws, she doesn’t suffer from agonizing teen angst like so many female characters in YA fiction.  The interaction between her and her loveable but befuddled mother is fantastic, as is her solid relationship with her outgoing fashion-junkie best friend, Kit. Every character is imbued with loveable quirks, and the setting is home to all these quirks.  I’ve never been to Berkeley, but in Prinz’s hands in becomes a funky neighbourhood, full of off-the-wall incense sellers, drugged-out drag queens, friendly falafel sellers, and everyone in between.  The crazy vibe of the place pulses through the novel.  It is hip, urban, and dingy enough to be both edgy and comfortable.

What makes this summer of Allie’s life different is that a) she’s started a blog and a zine about vinyl records (titled “The Vinyl Princess”); and that b) her record store is robbed, and she knows the guy who did it.  There are a few other source of drama, but the conflict in this novel is so mild that it really won’t trouble you.  Not to give too much away, but the zine and blog fairly quickly take off, and the robbery leads to serious, but not too major soul-searching.  She never breaks up with her best friend, disowns her mother, or contemplates leaving home/doing drugs/shagging the wrong guy/becoming a kleptomaniac/etc. etc.  It doesn’t take too much intuition to sort out a) who the “baddy” is; b) which guy she’ll end up with; c) which guy her mom will end up with; and d) what she’ll do with her life after her boss’s big announcement.  Some might be annoyed by this predictability, but I always find that in a well-written book, with great characters and scenes it doesn’t matter.  I can sit back and enjoy the ride, even though I know exactly where it’s going – truth be told, I kind of enjoy the comfortable predictability.

While it’s not full of world-ending drama, this book is funny and smart, and made me: a) ashamed that I’ve ever downloaded music; b) want to listed to the albums and playlists she describes; c) envious of her obvious blog success; and d) wishing I could know either Allie or Yvonne Prinz a whole lot better (I suspect it doesn’t matter which – Prinz is the co-founder of a record store in San Francisco, and I think she’s writing what she knows and loves).  It’s a perfect summer read, and I’m so glad I finally gave it a chance.

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Just Read, Young Adult books

Divergent by Veronica Roth

Divergent was just published in April 2011, and yes, it is another YA dystopian thriller. A few of my co-workers had read it and loved it (loved it!), and one insisted that I check it out.  And I have to say – I’m very glad I did.  I’ve just emerged from two straight days of reading (it would have been faster if I didn’t have a 6 month old to look after)… one of those marathons where I feel itchy and cranky when I’m not reading.  I love when a book sweeps me away like this, even though it makes me grouchy or completely useless for anything else.

Ok, the story.  I was actually not completely sold on the premise, as it seemed to be too overwrought when I first heard it.  But I’m learning that there might be no such thing as too implausible in this genre.  In this world, the people of the city (a future Chicago) are separated into five factions, each reflecting a virtue: Candor (honesty), Abnegation (selflessness), Dauntless (bravery), Amity (peacefulness) and Erudite (intelligence).  Fair enough – but my mind immediately went wondered why anyone would do this.  How does it make sense to organize a society in this way?  Who does it benefit – and if it’s meant to be fair and functional, then is it really a dystopia?  Moreover, the central point of the novel – that everyone is a mix of these virtues, or that they should be mixed, seems so obvious as to defy comment.  I mean, shouldn’t a good dystopia point out something that’s wrong with our society?  Take something that’s true of us today and exaggerate it?  Or point to a path we seem to be on, and show how it could lead to evil?  For example: destruction of the environment (Chrysalids, City of Ember, The Dirt Eaters); rule by a stifling dictatorship (1984, Hunger Games), or stifling people’s creativity and human spirit (The Giver and most of the above).  No one has ever actually proposed dividing society up by virtues – so I wasn’t sure what exactly Divergent was a critique of.  It must be just another grab at a crazy premise to get a book published, I thought.

Then I started reading, and within the first three pages, I pretty much forgot all my objections.  The writing is great – tense and terse.  The economy of language perfectly captures this character who begins as a member of the ascetic Abnegation faction:

“There is one mirror in my house.  It is behind a sliding panel in the hallway upstairs.  Our faction allows me to stand in front of it on the second day of every third month, the day my mother cuts my hair.”

Immediately gripping – and as it went on, I realized that it doesn’t suffer from the same problem as many of the books I’ve been reading have.  Roth doesn’t tell us who the character is, and what her hidden side is right away – she lets us discover it through details.  And the same for the other characters.  Usually we realize something before the main character does because of the careful placement of these clues.  In some cases the giveaway is too obvious (as in the love story), but on the whole it works very well.  It’s the old rule of showing not telling, and I wish more YA (and other) authors would remember it.

So the plot: the main character Beatrice is a sixteen-year-old member of the Abnegation faction, though she’s never felt selfless enough to completely fit in with her family or faction.  At age sixteen, everyone in her society is tested to see which of the five factions they belong in – then they must make a choice about which one they want to spend the rest of their lives in.  For some, this might mean leaving their birth faction and their families forever. But Beatrice is an exception – she is divergent, and displays the qualities of multiple factions: Abnegation, Dauntless and Erudite.  She must now keep this dangerous secret and choose which of these faction she will belong to.  Despite the pain of leaving home, Beatrice chooses Dauntless, and launches herself on a truly challenging path to become an initiate in a society that prizes bravery and danger above all else.  To succeed, she must face her greatest fears, but always hide her true self.

And of course there’s a love story.

So there you have it – great action, great writing, great driving plot (the ending was a little weak: there were all the usual questions about how villans always manage to let the good guys slip out of their grasp), and fantastic characters.  Definitely get this one if you are looking for a Hunger Games follow-up – so far it’s hands-down the best alternative I’ve read.

Leave a comment

Filed under Books I've Enjoyed, Dystopias, Just Read, Young Adult books

The Predicteds by Christine Seifert

A huge wave of dystopian novels aimed at teens is making its way on the market, attempting to cash in on the popularity of The Hunger Games.  The Predicteds is one of the most recent offerings in this genre (available Sept 2011).  I was actually kind of excited by this one’s arresting premise: imagine a test exists that can tell you who will commit a violent crime or become a drug addict, or become a teenage mom. How would we treat people who are predicted for these actions?

Daphne Wright has just moved to a small town whose high school students have recently been profiled with just this kind of test (which is an amazing co-incidence given that her mom helped create the test, but left the project because of moral objections over how the test was being used.  You think she’d want to avoid the selected communities where the test was piloted).  Not only is the town full of rednecks and a fair portion of narrow-minded citizens, all hell breaks loose once the predicted lists are released.  The kicker is that Jesse, the tall, handsome guy Daphne has fallen in love with, is predicted as a violent offender.  Added to that are the rumours that he stalked a former girlfiend, and accusations that he was involved in the violent assault of another girl (actually a very close friend of his).  Daphne is (of course) torn between her feelings for Jesse and her fear that the charges might be true.

I have to say – part of me hated this book, and part of me very much enjoyed it.  I have a feeling it will appeal to a lot of teen readers – if you liked Numbers, or series like Prettys or Gossip Girl, this might be the right read for you.  The writing is uneven, but has some very nice moments like this one:

“It’s a bright Friday morning with only two weeks of school left, the briefest hint of summer freedom already in the air.  The month of May is always better than real summer, because when the day is done, when the sun sets, there will still be as many summer days left as there were in the morning.”  Isn’t that a nice thought?  Oh – and I’m not really supposed to quote that until I check it against the completed manuscript, but I can’t be bothered.

What really rubbed me the wrong way was the obviousness of it all.  Once the mystery was cleared up, there weren’t any questions, or profound thoughts to hold on to.  It essentially was another example of segregation – something that’s been covered by other books, but much more effectively. Moreover, the test made no sense.  I accept that in a dystopian novel one has to let some improbabilities go – and just assume that in the future things work differently, or that they’ve found technological fixes to certain problems.  But I honestly can’t imagine a test that would tell you someone is destined to become a teen mom.  Isn’t that more down to the frailty of birth control sometimes?  Whatever happened to chance?  Unfortunately, I found it all very muddled and poorly explained.

I also found the book to be infuriating in terms of the judgements it cast out.  The main character believes (and the plot seems to bear out) that these small town yokels are narrow-minded and quick to ostracize.  Maybe that’s how it is in small towns – but aren’t there good things too?  It seemed unrelentingly negative to me.  Also, the main character is extremely critical of shopping and clothes, but is constantly supplying us with details about people’s clothing and how their style works or doesn’t work.  In general, she has a massive superiority complex, and I have a hard time imagining why some of these people would give her the time of day.  She is constantly snipping at them in her head, but still spends all her time with them.  I’m quite sure that in another book the character would realize a) that these people are aweful and not worth spending time with, even if they are popular; or b) that they’re not so bad, and that she’s being a conceted ass for thinking so.  She sort of comes to both realizations – but again, I found it muddled.

Bottom line is, if you’re looking for a dystopian book with a nice romantic storyline, I would recommend Matched by Ally Condie well before this one (that a was a very clever book!).

Leave a comment

Filed under Dystopias, Just Read, Young Adult books